(CNN) — After learning that Ashton Kutcher had landed in the hospital trying to follow Steve Jobs’ all-fruit diet, CNN reader Sumday had just one question: “All I really wanted to know was why this diet was bad?”
Jobs first fell for extreme diets during his freshman year of college, according to Walter Isaacson’s biography “Steve Jobs.” Jobs and his college friend Daniel Kottke became vegetarians after reading “Diet for a Small Planet.”
Then Jobs read “Mucusless Diet Healing System” by Arnold Ehret; Ehret believed in eating nothing but fruits and starchless vegetables like spinach, carrots and cucumbers. Jobs began with two-day fruit fasts, eventually going for a week or more. “I got into it in my typical nutso way,” Jobs told Isaacson.
Ehret’s fruitarian diet, also called the Eden Garden Diet or Ehretism, is often used as a type of cleanse, according to LiveStrong.com. Designed to detoxify the system, it can do more long-term harm than good.
When you only eat fruit, you’re excluding a lot of valuable nutrients from your diet, says Marisa Moore, registered dietician and spokeswoman for the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics.
“Protein is one of the main ones that comes to mind,” she says. “(Without protein) you lose body weight. Protein acts like a building block for your muscles and skin and organs.”
The same goes for fats, Moore says. Although they often get demonized, fats play an important role in our hormone levels and brain function.
Kutcher told reporters at the Sundance Film Festival that he ended up in the hospital with pancreas levels that were “completely out of whack.”
Fruit contains a lot of natural sugar, which needs to be controlled by insulin in the body, Moore says. It’s the pancreas’ job to release that insulin; Kutcher’s pancreas may have been overworked if his body was receiving an overload of sugar.
Many readers wondered if an all-fruit diet could have led to Jobs’ pancreatic cancer, which led to his death in October 2011. Scientists don’t know what causes pancreatic cancer, according to the American Cancer Society. Certain inherited DNA mutations might play a role, as well as chemicals in our environment or diet.
Even if you don’t overwork your pancreas, you’re probably not eating enough calories on an all-fruit diet, Moore says. That puts the body into starvation mode, which can result in serious medical conditions like osteoporosis, severe dehydration and even heart failure, according to the National Eating Disorders Association.
Here’s the bottom line: Fruit is natural. It’s nutritious. Thegovernment recommends eating 1 to 2 cups of it a day. Just don’t go all “nutso” on it.